"It's getting dark on old Broadway". African American theatre of the Harlem Renaissance in search of the right direction (PDF)

Seminar paper from the year 2011 in the subject Didactics - English - History of Literature, Eras, grade: 2,0, Free University of Berlin, language: English, abstract: [...] When Gilda Gray performed "It's Getting Dark on Old Broadway" in the opening show of the
song-and-dance revue Ziegfeld Follies on 5 June 1922 she eternalized Broadway's latest
trend (Woll 76). Black entertainment proliferated in the Theatre District along Broadway in
the 1920s and it seemed that black shows had made it into the limelight of success. There
was, however, a different 'dark' side to the developments of the black performance scene.
To many leading intellectuals of the Harlem Renaissance, the new darkness on
Broadway looked rather bleak. Important figures like W. E. B. Du Bois who campaigned for a
new racial identity through cultural creation (cf. Du Bois "Criteria of Negro Art") feared that
the new phenomenon of black productions reaching out for mainstream success would
betray their cause. In his speech at the NAACP's annual conference, he famously claimed
that "all Art is propaganda and ever must be" (Du Bois par. 29). Catering to the white public's
demands (pars. 33, 35), as the successful Black Broadway musicals did, would mean failing
the cause, according to Du Bois. While some scholars argue that theatre and performance in
the New Negro era played "a pivotal role in the evolution of Black Nationalism" (Krasner 1),
those are opposed by a number of authors who look upon the Harlem Renaissance as a
failure (cf. Baker xiii, Neal 39, Krasner 95f.).
In the following paper, I will look into the question of whether the performers and
artists of the Harlem Renaissance really failed to contribute to a change of white America's
attitude toward the African American race (Krasner 14). One point at issue will be whether
the increasing success and commercialisation of Black theatre counteracted the objectives of
racial renewal or if on the contrary, they were a means to an end. [...]